Tuesday, January 26, 2010

Epigenetics, BPA, and Can I really live without plastic?

A couple weeks ago, the cover story in TIME magazine was on epigenetics. The whole concept of epigenetics is really fascinating and quite distressing to think about. We all know that evolution is a process which takes a very long time to change a species, so if you think in grand evolutional terms, nothing you do (smoking, drinking, eating a poor diet, etc) will affect your DNA or that of your children…. right? Well, this whole epigenetics thing says pretty much the opposite. There are apparently genetic markers, or switches, which tell certain genes to turn on and others to turn off. Genetic markers for certain things – good and bad – can be turned on and off in response to things such as smoking, drinking, poor diet, etc. And here’s the kicker. If one of these markers is switched on/off in *your* DNA, you will most likely pass on that “switch” to your offspring, and they in turn will most likely pass it on to theirs. It can take several generations for this “switch” to work its way out of your family’s DNA. [Here's what wikipedia has to say on the subject.]

I am certainly not an expert on epigenetics after reading one article, and it does seem to be a rather new field of study, so there’s much in that area still to be learned. However, after reading it, I began thinking very seriously about ways to change things in my life to keep my body healthy – mainly along the lines of eating more fruits and vegetables, keeping in line with my first New Year’s Resolution. Two of my closest friends recently had children, and I guess my biological clock is ticking, because I’ve been wanting to make sure I’m not going to pass on any bizarre DNA switches to any kids *I* might one day have.

Recently I listened to two different podcasts of NPR news shows, both of which addressed the issue of BPA (Bisphenol A) in plastics and its effects (or potential effects) on human health. (The podcasts were
Diane Rehm's second hour on January 20, 2010 and Talk of the Nation Science Friday from January 22, 2010. To read about BPA on wikipedia, click here.) Scientists are only just now beginning to understand the effects of BPA upon the human organism, which makes one wonder what *other* chemicals in plastic negatively impact human health. I went grocery shopping right after listening to one podcast, and was in the middle of the other when I pulled into the parking lot. Inspired (or perhaps frightened) by what I’d heard, I decided to try to cut back on the amount of plastics that I purchased.

And I pretty much failed. My one success was buying cream cheese in the cardboard packet, instead of in the plastic tub. Everything else…. well, take a look:

Photobucket
Cookies, in a plastic container, wrapped in plastic.
Should I start baking??

Photobucket
Organic Spinach....
encased in plastic, with the evil number 7 (explained below)

Photobucket
I *love* trail mix. But if I'm not carrying it on the trail (or to class, work, etc) in this bag, what should I carry it in? If I'm ruling out plastic, that rules out Ziploc!

Photobucket
Yogurt.

Photobucket
When you buy veggies at the grocery store,
you're supposed to put them in these bags.

Photobucket
Granola and Triscuits. Should I empty the contents out of the plastic bags and directly into the cardboard boxes?

Photobucket
Again with the organic veggies encased in plastic

One of the scientists I’d heard interviewed on NPR had a tip for finding the “healthier” plastics: Many (but definitely not all) plastics have a recycle symbol with a number in the center. Take a look at the number and remember this little rhyme, “Four, five, one, and two, everything else is bad for you.” Of all the plastic products I’d purchased, only *two* had a recycling symbol with a number: The yogurt had an acceptable 5…. while the organic spinach was encased in a BPA-bearing 7! Additionally, after returning home I was shocked to upend my Nalgene water bottle to discover that it bore a number 7 as well! Nalgene was supposed to be the environmentally healthy way of drinking water, avoiding the waste of plastic water bottles… although apparently it’s been poisoning me with BPA! (A quick google search shows that Nalgene is now marketing BPA-free water bottles.) Then there’s the fact that I cannot drink tap water at my house. Not only do I have city water, but I have old, rusty plumbing. The stuff that comes out of my tap tastes pretty foul. As a result, I use a Brita filtration pitcher – all plastic, with no number on it to give me a clue as to whether or not it’s got any BPA. (According to several sites such as this one, Brita claims its products are made of BPA-free plastic.)

Photobucket
My Brita pitcher and Nalgene bottle

So what do I replace my Nalgene bottle with? Do they make glass or ceramic Brita filtration pitchers? What about Tupperware? Or those new Ziploc super-cheap alternatives to Tupperware? What about plastic wrap? What about all the food I bought, encased in plastic? What about all the plastic Christmas “tins” that I use for my cat and dog food bowls? (Surely if it’s bad for me to ingest, it’s bad for my critters, too, although they bear the number 5, one of the “acceptable” numbers.) Gah! And let’s not even think about the fact that almost all canned foods are in cans that are lined on the inside with a BPA-containing sealant.

If you start thinking about all of the food/beverage related plastics, it suddenly gets really overwhelming. Would it actually be possible to eliminate all of these things from my life? And if so, would it be something affordable, or would I have to spend much, much more in order to do it? (My friend Brenda
sent me this link to a place to buy all sorts of glass storage containers. I am going to slowly start collecting them.... too bad I'm so poor!!) If these chemicals are in everything and are so pervasive, would I actually be able to make a difference in my health (and my epigenetics) by getting rid of them?

14 comments:

Rhiannon said...

Jane, I agree that it is truly disheartening to see all the poisons around us. One thing that occurs to me as I see you trying to eliminate your plastic usage -- do you have a co-op near you, or a store with bulk bins? You could get granola, etc and put them in your own bags. Etsy has a lot if you search for "vegetable bags" and some of them are quite reasonable. I'm thinking of being ultra cheap, though, and buying some muslin and sewing my own. I hate that we have to spend so much time/$/energy trying to fend off some of the toxic things that companies can use to make cheap products.

Good luck in your journey toward plastic elimination. :) I'd love to hear how it goes and to exchange more tips!

annie said...

Sadly, we don't. The shopping options around here are Wal-Mart, Kroger, and Food Lion. You'd think that in such a rural area, it would be easier to come by more natural products, but it really isn't. There's an alleged "farmer's market" but I've yet to see anyone there selling anything :-(

Anonymous said...

Yes, it's scary. A lot of BPA-Free bottles were coming out when Madeline was born. But I bough glass because I figured that just because it's BPA-Free doesn't mean it's safe. They've been saying forever that BPA is safe (the industry still says it's safe) - so who knows what else is in there and not yet known. Because of that, I try to stay away from plastics. It's impossible to avoid, but I do a few things. First - I drink out of glass or, if on the go Stainless Steel (I.e. Klean Kanteen, though there are now cheap alternatives - just make sure that the alternatives are 100% food grade stainless steel). A lot of people switched over to Sigg to avoid BPA- I didn't because they are Aluminum and I figured Brenda wouldn't approve - then come to find out Siggs had BPA in their lining!!. 2nd - I'm switching over to glass storage containers. It's a slow process, but you can also save your used glass tomato and pb jars. I still use a lot of plastic storage, but I try not to put anything hot or fatty in there as both cause leaching. Joy also bought me a lunch set from Etsy that has sandwich bags made of wool(?). 3rd - I have an under the counter water purifier. Let me know if you want a link. IMO this is the safest option that's reasonably affordable. I just try to forget about the time the water spends in the pipes coming from the streets (often plastic) and who know where it's been before that. 4th - I try not to use plastic in the grocery. Like Rhiannon says, you can buy cheap bags on Etsy in natural materials. And of course it's greener. 5th I try to not buy stuff in packages, but it's very hard. This is the most important step, IMO, because in most packaged food, the plastic is the least of your worries!! I'm joining a CSA for the summer, so that will help. A lot of stuff you can make yourself. Alex has been making bread - it's delicious. Also - did you know that if you buy "preservative free" bread it is perfectly legal for them to put it in a package treated with preservatives that seeps into the bread while stored!

At the end of the day - there's nothing you can do about exposure to plastic and it's only going to get worse, probably. I just try to do what I can and forget the rest.

Anonymous said...

The scariest part of this whole thing is that plastic is just the tip of the toxic iceberg.

Anonymous said...

Last but not least - I highly recommend CSAs. Here's two in your area.

http://www.localharvest.org/search-csa.jsp?map=1&lat=31.218893&lon=-82.373503&scale=8&ty=6&nm=&zip=31503

Melissa

John from Daejeon said...

Those vegetables look pricey. What happened to your garden?

Amanda said...

A lot of places don't even recycle number 5 plastics, even though they are recyclable. Google "Gimme Five plastic" and you'll find a company that does recycle it. They collect at select Whole Foods or via mail.

I've heard good things about the Crate and Barrel stuff. Living near a Korean market, we just buy the beloved Lock&Lock glass containers.

As for water bottles, you can get glass ones, or metal ones.

Another option for the Britta filter (oh! And the filters can also be recycled through Gimme Five) is to filter the water into the plastic and then immediately transfer it over to a glass pitcher.

We haven't fully gotten rid of plastic (still love my plastic lunch storage stuff) but we're trying to move to glass. And we've quit microwaving in plastic, at least...

laurie said...

It is a shame that I have so many more non-big box options for food here in NYC than you do in a rural area where you are probably closer to actual farmers (though there are lots of small farms in upstate NY that provide the goods for our farmer's markets). Maybe you could start the green revolution in GA? I bet my cousin and his fiance would help! Till then, there are a lot of blogs and such on the interwebs devoted to living w/o plastic. Something tells me you probably already know that. ;)

annie said...

Melissa - sadly of the two CSAs, one seems to have closed, and the other is full :-( I'll keep looking though - I really like that idea.

John - gardening is something it seems I can only do when I have a lot of free time. My peas did really well, my spinach didn't grow at all... and I didn't have time to plant anything after that! :-(

Amanda - I like the GimmeFive thing - this area is so totally lacking in recycling options :-(

Laurie - it is really amazing how people in the big cities really do have more access to such things, whereas those of us in rural areas (other than farmers) do not. I was thinking just the other day of how many alternatives existed in San Diego than do here!

John from Daejeon said...

Laurie, I’m from a farming family, and Jane is right about selling your wares where you can make the most money. Most small farmers from my rural neck of the woods will drive for hours on end to the big cities of Houston, Dallas, and San Antonio rather than make a pittance from the fewer inhabitants in the closer surrounding small cities and towns. On a more distressing note, thinking globally will start raising prices in local supermarkets even more as farmers (like my uncle who is now doing this) are no longer growing for the domestic market. My uncle now grows Chinese/Napa cabbage instead of regular American cabbage and ships it overseas for the Chinese and Asian markets where he can get a much better price.

John from Daejeon said...

By the way, the magazine "Mother Earth News" just ran a great article about 40 Farmers Under 40.
http://www.mnn.com/food/farms-gardens/stories/40-farmers-under-40

Number 40 is very interesting, especially since she is making a film about small-time "green" farmers like these called "Greenhorns" while she continues to actually farm. I can't wait to see the finished film, but you can see the trailer in the on-line article.

Anonymous said...

hey ... just a comment ... epigenetics (or silencing of gene expression) is essential for development ... for example ... a cell that will become a neuron does not need to express proteins for muscles ... so they will be silenced in neurons ... thru epigenetics .. :)
.. just a comment ...
rod

annie said...

John - Thanks for that link - it's very inspiring. If only I had more time to devote to such things. I had no idea Jason Mraz was into farming. (I remember him from the San Diego music scene, from back when I lived in SD)

Rod - I'm not saying that there's anything unnatural or problematic about epigenetics itself, it's just that it has made me realize that we all have to be very careful about how we treat our bodies, and as a result, what traits we pass on to our children.

Anonymous said...

thanks for the link back to my blog. all this is disheartening, but it is good to know we can do something about it and vote with our wallets!! i'm finding that living a little more naturally and avoiding toxics is not that difficult and in many ways is cheaper than traditional cleaners, body products, etc.

Good luck on your journey, and thanks again for the link back!

Trisha
www.amomsblog.wordpress.com