Sunday, January 21, 2007

Atlas Shrugged

This month I’ve been reading Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged. It was definitely a daunting task; not only is the book 1074 pages long, but I swear it was printed in size 8 font. I’ve been squinting my way through the thing for the past few weeks, and I finally succeeded in finishing it late last night. I had previously read, enjoyed and reviewed two other of Rand’s books: We The Living (review) and The Fountainhead (review). The discussions I had with my coworkers and the comments that appeared in my blog following my review of The Fountainhead prompted me to read Atlas Shrugged. Of course, I was able to read The Fountainhead while in Russia because we had it in the library at my school. Not having access to Atlas Shrugged at the time, I decided that it would be one of the books filling the huge box of reading materials I shipped to Korea. I must admit that I picked it up several times… only to put it down and select something lighter (both physically and conceptually; this isn’t one of those books that you can hold with one hand).

I finally kicked myself into gear and began reading Atlas Shrugged a few weeks ago. I admit that it was difficult to get into at first. The first two-hundred pages of the book are *very* similar to The Fountainhead. True, the characters had different names and worked in different industries, but I found very little difference. I considered putting it down; why should I squint my way through over 1000 pages of size 8 font if it’s the same story told with different characters? Luckily, it didn’t quite turn out that way. Around two hundred pages in, the book finally began to evolve past the themes presented in The Fountainhead, and actually got quite interesting, and stayed that way until its conclusion (well, except for Galt’s speech, which I felt really could have been substantially shorter). As with my little post on The Fountainhead, I’m not going to give you an in-depth analysis or blow-by blow account of the book; there are plenty of those out there for you to read if you’re interested. Or you could simply read the book for yourself.

I don’t agree with everything that Rand says, but over the course of reading her works, I have found that I agree with a lot that she has to say. I have been told that Ayn Rand would not support
my hermit lifestyle because I am not being a productive capitalist. I do rather beg to differ. Look at the oath which the protagonists must take when they join with John Galt:

“I swear – by my life and my love of it – that I will never live for the sake of another man, nor ask any other to live for mine.”

The heart of my personal philosophy has a lot to do with living my life the way *I* choose, the way I want, and supporting myself, instead of doing the sorts of things that are expected of me and living my life the way most Americans do – shackled to insurmountable debts.

To my good friend (he knows who he is) who believes that leading an altruistic life is the only way to be happy, and who told me that if I read Atlas Shrugged, I would cease to agree with Rand and start to agree with him… Well, I don’t.

I definitely enjoyed this book, even though I wish that Rand could have shortened it by a couple hundred pages. Like I stated above, I don’t agree with everything that Rand has to say. For instance, I do believe in the existence of nonprofit and charity organizations; however, I also feel that very few people have the right to subsist solely on charity. Also, I find Rand’s portrayal of sex (in all of her books) to be disturbingly violent. I agree with her that sex should be celebrated – and that a person should only engage in sexual acts with those who hold the same values he or she possesses. But why do her descriptions of sex often border on rape? That disturbs me. But other than that… I found myself nodding in agreement throughout most of the book. So go get yourself a copy and let me know what you think.

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

I have actually refused to go on dates with otherwise perfectly fine men when they've admitting to liking Rand.

annie said...

Oh dear! Why don't you like her?

Anonymous said...

I, too, was in agreement with much of 'Atlas Shrgged', which I read 40+ years ago. And yet, according to Frank, I'm a socialist.

Anonymous said...

I am perfectly fine with people living on charity. If buisnesses refuse to pay adequate wages while benifiting from tax breaks and a regressive tax system, while the majority of new improvements and developments come from sales taxes which are hardest on the poorest of Americans, I am perfectly fine with people living on charity. As Melissa would say, why buy the cow when you can get the milk for free. Why work for a company that cares nothing for you and pays you subsistence standard wages, when you can more than subsist on welfare, become a sofa Diva, and get a check sent to you every month. Hell enjoy sex in what ever fashion you want, pop out a few kids, and let the good times roll. I know that sounds a little socalist of me, but haveing seen the social fabric in France and participated within their family unit, its incredible to say the least. In Claire family, we eat every meal together, the parents have time to spend with their children and do, and there seems to be very few social anxiety disorders. I am all about time over money, and if charities or the government can help you achieve that form of lifestyle through higher taxes then I am all for it. Of course, I also believe that it can stifle productivity and drive, and if there is only one truth in this world, French people do not like to work. Well, Claire is a little different, but her buisness is a little different. With that said, French people travel a great deal on their pittance of wages which is more than I can say for Americans. Oh well, there is more to read. And yes, Jane, I do not belueve that Rand would care for your lifestyle, but at least you are following what makes you happy. I used to share an office with a guy who loved both Ayn Rand and Thomas Jefferson and had pictures of both of them posted all over the walls, it was a misserable experience to say the least. Oh well, hope that everything is allright.
Thanks for the camera tip.

Christopher

Anonymous said...

I really liked Ann Rand myself, though she was a little too hard-core "screw the poor" for my tastes. I am in favor of having at least some limited bootstrap-type social safety net for those who cannot provide for themselves. I think Ayn Rand would use the poor for kindling and never shed a tear.

That John Galt speech was really long, though.

Anonymous said...

Why don't I like Rand? High school debate, a bad English teacher, meeting too many people who worship her, majoring in Philosophy in college (no, it wasn't a case of a bad philosophy class about Rand, more my profs' biases)...your pick.

(I have a much older mentor-friend who said, "Oh dear, are people considering her philosophy? Since when?")

When my ex-fiance started reading her, I was especially glad it was over between us. ^^

Anonymous said...

Hi Jane!

I really enjoy your blog. While I enjoyed Ayn Rand's books, and especially the film version of The Fountainhead with Patricia Neal and the great Gary Cooper as Howard Roark, I find my time better spent reading Robert A. Heinlein. Sometimes I think Stranger In A Strange Land was written just for me because I see my life, and beliefs, as being out of phase with so much in this world. You can't go wrong with a single one of the greatest Sci-Fi writer's works. Just finished The Moon is a Harsh Mistress and Farmhan's Freehold, and I will watch Starship Troopers later tonight. Keep up the blogging, and how can I go about getting a copy of your book? I'm here in Daejeon. Can it be shipped here? Maybe I can exchange some of my books for yours.

my email is jawick@hotmail.com

Anonymous said...

http://www.tcm.com/video/videoPlayer/?cid=20821&titleId=596

Just watched the trailer for The Fountainhead, so now I guess I'll re-watch it again tonight as well.

Anonymous said...

Hmm. I just watched that trailer john posted and it's a bit strange to see "The Fountainhead" promoted as a romantic movie.

I've only read "Fountainhead," but I enjoyed it a lot. If her other books are similar, I might have to mosey on over and pick them up.

I have to agree with Amanda though: Even though I like Rand, I wouldn't want to date a guy passionate about her work.